CLA News / Beyond Declarations: Strengthening Democracy Through Meaningful Action by Steven Thiru, President, Commonwealth Lawyers Association

19/11/2026
Share

This is an updated version of the remarks delivered by CLA President Steven Thiru at the ‘Safeguarding Democracy: Implementing the Nadi Declaration’ panel on 3 November 2026. The panel formed part of an event on ‘Safeguarding Democracy and Inclusion in the Commonwealth’, hosted by the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association and the Parliament of Antigua and Barbuda on the sidelines of the 28th Commonwealth Heads of Government (‘CHOGM’) Meeting in Antigua and Barbuda.

Democracy and the Imperative of Institutional Independence

Democratic resilience depends on independent public institutions. When their independence is undermined, the foundations of constitutional democracy crumble. Through the Nadi Declaration on Democratic Resilience and Participation, Commonwealth member states have unequivocally reaffirmed their commitment to upholding the rule of law, enhancing access to justice, and ensuring the structural integrity of legal systems.

Adopted by Commonwealth Law Ministers in February 2026, the Declaration provides a framework for advancing democratic resilience through good governance, human rights, respect for the rule of law, and citizen participation, with the aim of supporting democratic consolidation, preventing democratic backsliding, and bolstering democratic institutions.

Under the heading “Upholding the Rule of Law”, member states expressly undertake to “promote [the] independence, impartiality, and effectiveness of the judiciary”. A judiciary subject to the dictates of the Executive risks becoming an instrument of government policy dressed in judicial robes, rather than an independent arbiter of the law.

The consequences of failing to protect judicial independence are captured in the words of Malaysia’s former Lord President, Tun Mohamed Suffian Hashim: “Those who stand by and do nothing to protect the independence of the judiciary will in the end get a judiciary they deserve – one powerless to stand between them and tyranny.”

A legal profession whose independence is compromised is a canary in the coalmine of democratic backsliding. An authoritarian lurch often begins with attempts to manipulate and intimidate the legal profession and its professional associations.

The Nadi Declaration also calls upon member states to “[s]upport legislative and regulatory reforms to enhance access to justice, legal certainty, and accountability”. These objectives cannot be fully realised without an independent, fearless, and self-governing Bar.

In March 2025, the Council of Europe adopted the landmark Convention for the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer (‘Luxembourg Convention’), the first treaty designed to establish binding international obligations specifically dedicated to safeguarding the independence of lawyers and their professional associations. It sets an international gold standard for translating aspirational norms into enforceable legal requirements.

The Luxembourg Convention is open to accession by all countries after it enters into force. If Commonwealth states are resolute about giving effect to the Nadi Declaration, they must commit to becoming parties to the Luxembourg Convention through ratification or accession, as applicable. This would signal to the world that within the Commonwealth, protecting lawyers and the independence of the profession are commitments to be upheld in practice, not merely proclaimed.

Corruption and the Erosion of Democratic Governance

Notably, under “Strengthening Good Governance”, the Nadi Declaration calls on Commonwealth member states to “[s]upport anti-corruption initiatives and mechanisms for ethical public administration”. Corruption is not merely a financial or economic crime; it is an insidious attack on constitutional democracy.

An anti-corruption commission that is subject to undue executive influence risks becoming a political instrument. Selective enforcement — investigating and prosecuting political opponents with ruthless efficiency while regime loyalists and corrupt political benefactors enjoy impunity — erodes public confidence and the rule of law from within.

To implement the Nadi Declaration, Commonwealth states should ensure that anti-corruption agencies operate under stable legal frameworks, with adequate and reliable resources, financial autonomy, and independence from undue influence. These principles are reflected in two important international instruments: the Jakarta Statement on Principles for Anti-Corruption Agencies and the United Nations Convention against Corruption.

Media Freedom and the Protection of Democratic Space

Under “Promoting Citizen Participation”, the Nadi Declaration calls for wider opportunities for “meaningful public engagement in democratic decisionmaking, policy formulation and oversight”. Such participation depends on transparent information ecosystems and the protection of fundamental freedoms. A free and independent media is indispensable, yet media organisations, professional and citizen journalists, and other independent voices across the Commonwealth and beyond are enduring systematic assault.

The International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists was observed on 2 November. UNESCO reports that a staggering number of journalists have been killed for carrying out their work and informing the public: 1,641 since 2006, equivalent to one every four days, on average. Six out of seven of these cases remain ongoing or unresolved — an impunity rate of 86%.

This institutional vulnerability within our own family of nations was laid bare in a 2025 joint report co-authored by the CLA, titled Who Controls the Narrative? Legal Restrictions on Freedom of Expression in the Commonwealth. It examines how Commonwealth Governments have weaponised restrictive laws, including archaic penal provisions, to muzzle investigative journalism, suppress dissent, and criminalise legitimate scrutiny of public authority.

This status quo is indefensible and cuts directly against the Nadi Declaration’s core undertakings. Commonwealth member states must have robust and independent mechanisms to conduct investigations, break the cycle of impunity, and ensure that those who speak truth to power are protected by law, not punished for doing so.

The Rule of Law Beyond National Borders

The core tenets of the Nadi Declaration — which include the rule of law, institutional independence, and accountability — must be defended internationally. A rules-based international order relies on independent international institutions, which have come under unprecedented attack. Commonwealth states must therefore stand united in defending those institutions and the principles on which they are founded.

The sanctions imposed by the United States (‘US’) against the International Criminal Court (‘ICC’) are a direct assault that illustrates the challenges facing international institutions. Under Executive Order 14203, issued on 6 February 2025, Washington first imposed asset freezes, travel bans, and financial sanctions against individual ICC judges and prosecutors. On 9 October 2026, announcing the extension of US sanctions to the ICC itself as an institution, the US Secretary of State issued an explicit ultimatum: “Either the ICC will end its threats, or we will end the ICC.”

The principles underpinning the Nadi Declaration must also be applied consistently. States cannot credibly champion an independent domestic judiciary while simultaneously taking measures that risk undermining international judicial institutions, particularly when their decisions are unwelcome or contrary to national interests.

Under its priority on “Protecting and Advancing Human Rights”, the Nadi Declaration calls on member states to “[p]rotect and advance the equal enjoyment of fundamental civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights”. That commitment rests on a broader truth: human rights are not the private or domestic preserve of any ruling government; they are universal and inalienable obligations solemnly undertaken in international covenants.

The Indian author and activist Arundhati Roy has spoken of the need to “globalize dissent”. Just as tyranny, oppression, and lawlessness globalise their techniques, sharing playbook strategies on surveillance and using cross-border Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (‘SLAPPs’) to muzzle dissent, so too must the defence of human rights be international in reach. A human rights violation anywhere is a threat to the rule of law everywhere.

From Advocacy to Application: Rule of Law in Action

Public statements remain an important part of the CLA’s advocacy, but they are not enough on their own. We must move beyond words through what I would call a ‘Rule of Law in Action’ initiative, tailored to the exigencies of the challenges and, where necessary, involving ‘boots on the ground’. This means using our legal training, skills, and experience through practical engagement, advice, litigation, and other forms of support. This may include litigation that secures adjudication before an independent court, seeking opportunities to intervene as amici curiae, and undertaking public advocacy alongside local Bar associations.

There is no one-size-fits-all solution or textbook method. Our responses must reflect local circumstances while advancing the rule of law and reinforcing the independence of the legal profession.

The CLA’s recent intervention in Sri Lanka illustrates this approach. At the invitation of the Bar Association of Sri Lanka, I travelled to Colombo in early September 2026 to observe Supreme Court proceedings challenging the constitutionality of the proposed 22nd Amendment to the Constitution, which sought to raise the retirement age of judges. The CLA maintained a watching brief, sought leave to intervene as amicus curiae, and subsequently published a detailed report highlighting serious procedural irregularities and the implications for public confidence in the administration of justice and the perception of judicial independence.

We experienced first-hand how ‘globalising dissent’ and engaging advocacy for institutional independence may attract political criticism. The Justice Minister of Sri Lanka dismissed the CLA as an irrelevant and unrecognised entity, describing it as “a club for fee-paying members”. Such responses should not deter independent Bar associations and international law organisations from discharging their responsibilities. Those who stand up for institutional independence will never be alone — and must know that they are not alone.

The CLA will not be fazed. We will continue to speak out against abuses of power, challenge executive overreach, and defend the independence of courts and advocates, within and beyond our borders.

The Nadi Declaration on Democratic Resilience and Participation provides the strategic blueprint for this work. But a declaration that sits on a shelf changes nothing. Without action and implementation, it will be consigned to the dustbin of history as just another collection of pious platitudes. Democracy that fails to protect its weakest members is a false democracy. The erosion of democratic institutions also brings a longer-term cost: declining public trust and growing voter apathy. Restoring that trust requires leadership, accountability, and the willingness to act.

The true test of the Nadi Declaration will be whether member states translate its commitments into concrete action, with the Commonwealth monitoring progress, holding states accountable, and providing practical assistance. Only then will the Declaration become more than an expression of shared values — and the rule of law more than a distant promise.

Steven Thiru

President

Commonwealth Lawyers Association

3 November 2026

Steven Thiru records his appreciation to Jaishanker Sadananda and Chin Oy Sim for their assistance in preparing these remarks.